Is Renting Out Your Home the Right Move?

j

Written by PJ Burns

Published February 2, 2025

Have you ever thought about turning your home into a rental property? For many military families and government employees, frequent relocations, such as Permanent Change of Station (PCS) orders, create unique opportunities to generate income by renting out a home instead of selling it. Whether you’re looking to cover your mortgage, build equity, or create a steady stream of passive income, renting out your property can be a smart financial move. However, like any major decision, it comes with its own set of challenges and considerations. From understanding local rental laws to preparing your home for tenants, a little preparation can make all the difference in ensuring your rental journey is successful and stress-free. This guide walks you through everything you need to know before taking the plunge into property management.

What’s Your Game Plan? Define Your Goals Before Renting

Before renting out your home, it’s important to clarify your reasons for doing so. Your motivation can shape every decision you make, from setting rental prices to choosing between managing the property yourself or hiring a professional. Many military families or government employees choose to rent out their homes during a PCS move, seeing it as a way to generate passive income while preserving a valuable asset. Others might aim to take advantage of a strong local rental market or offset mortgage costs while transitioning to a new duty station.

Knowing your “why” also helps you determine whether renting is the right choice for you. By defining your purpose upfront, you’ll be better equipped to make strategic decisions and avoid potential pitfalls down the road. 

Questions to Refine Your Game Plan

  • What’s My Financial Goal? Cover expenses, generate profit, or build equity?
  • How Long Do I Plan to Rent? Temporary income or a long-term investment?
  • Am I Comfortable Being a Landlord? Should I hire a property manager?
  • What’s the Local Rental Market Like? High demand or a more competitive environment?
  • What Are My Backup Plans? In case of vacancies or unexpected costs.

Does Renting Financially Make Sense

Renting out your home can be a smart financial move, but it requires careful planning. Here’s a simplified guide to help you assess if renting is financially smart:

  1. Cash Flow
  • Estimate Your Rental Income
    • Research similar properties in your area by checking online platforms like Zillow, Rentometer, or Craigslist, and use these listings as a baseline. Focus on properties similar in size, location, and features to your own. 
    • When researching comparable rental properties, aim to find ones within a 1-3 mile radius of your home. This ensures they are in the same general market area and influenced by similar factors like schools, amenities, and transportation. Always prioritize comparables in the same neighborhood or school district when possible, as these details significantly affect rental demand and pricing.
  • Understand Your Expenses
    • Mortgage: Your monthly loan payment.
    • Property Taxes: Check your county website for the annual amount.
    • Insurance: Use a quote for landlord insurance.
    • Maintenance: Plan to set aside 5-7% of your rental income for regular upkeep.
    • Capital Expenditures: Budget about 7% of rent for major repairs or replacements, like a new roof or HVAC system.
    • Utilities: If you’ll cover utilities, estimate the monthly costs and include them in your calculations.
    • Property Management: Even if you plan to self-manage, budget 10% of rent for potential management fees. This allows flexibility if you decide to hire a professional later.
  • Plan for Unexpected Costs
    • Remember, vacancies happen—assume your property will be rented about 92% of the time, accounting for one vacant month annually.
    • It’s essential to build a reserve covering 3-6 months of expenses to handle unexpected costs like emergency repairs, evictions, or vacancies. Early on, rental income may not be enough to cover these expenses, so having this financial cushion ensures you can manage issues without straining your budget or risking your property investment.
  • Calculate Cash Flow

Now, bring it all together to determine whether renting out your home will generate a profit. Use this formula:

(Annual Rental Income x Occupancy Rate) – Total Expenses = Net Cash Flow

Example:

  • Annual Rental Income: $2,000/month x 12 months = $24,000
  • Occupancy Adjustment: $24,000 x 0.92 (92% occupancy) = $22,080
  • Expenses: Mortgage ($12,000), Property Taxes ($2,000), Insurance ($1,000), Maintenance (7% = $1,544), Capital Expenditures (7% = $1,544), Management Fees (10% = $2,208) = $20,296
  • Net Cash Flow: $22,080 – $20,296 = $1,784/year ($149/month)

If the cash flow is positive, the property is a solid investment. If not, consider adjusting the rent (within market limits) or exploring ways to reduce expenses.

  1. Appreciation 

Appreciation, or the increase in a property’s value over time, is a key factor in determining whether renting makes financial sense. For landlords, it contributes to long-term wealth by growing equity and enhancing returns on investment (ROI).

Appreciation is driven by:

  • Market Demand: Growing populations or job opportunities boost housing values.
  • Upgrades: Renovations like updated kitchens or landscaping increase home value.
  • Inflation: Rising costs push property values higher.
  • Location Trends: Proximity to new infrastructure or amenities enhances appeal.

Why It Matters for Landlords

  • Equity Growth: Rising property values build equity that can be leveraged for future investments.
  • Increased Rental Potential: Higher values often lead to higher rent over time.
  • Resale Profits: Appreciation boosts your profit when selling, especially with tax benefits like the Section 121 exclusion.

Maximizing Appreciation

  • Invest in areas with strong job markets and future development.
  • Maintain and improve the property to add value.
  • Hold the property long-term to benefit from natural market growth.

Appreciation can significantly improve the financial case for renting, but it works best when balanced with strong cash flow and manageable expenses.

  1. Depreciation

Depreciation is a tax benefit that allows landlords to deduct the gradual wear and tear of their property over time, reducing taxable rental income. While it’s a non-cash expense, depreciation can significantly improve the financial viability of renting out your home.

The IRS lets you depreciate the value of your rental property (excluding the land) over 27.5 years. This means you can deduct a portion of the property’s value each year.

  • Example:
    • If the building is worth $275,000, divide that by 27.5 years:
    • $275,000 ÷ 27.5 = $10,000.
    • You can deduct $10,000 annually from your taxable rental income.

Why Depreciation Matters

  • Lowers Taxable Income: Depreciation reduces the income you report to the IRS, potentially saving thousands in taxes annually.
  • Improves Cash Flow: Since it’s a non-cash expense, you benefit from the tax savings without affecting your monthly rental income.

Important Considerations

  • Recapture at Sale: When you sell the property, the IRS requires you to “recapture” depreciation and pay taxes on it, usually at a rate of 25%.
  • Professional Advice: The rules can be complex, especially if you’ve lived in the home before renting it. Consult a tax professional to ensure accurate reporting.

Depreciation is a powerful tool for landlords, offering significant tax advantages that make owning rental property more financially rewarding. While the benefits are substantial, understanding the recapture process and tax rules is essential for long-term planning.

  1. Equity

Equity is the portion of your property that you truly own—the difference between your home’s market value and the amount you still owe on the mortgage. Building equity over time is one of the biggest financial advantages of owning and renting out real estate.

Equity increases in two main ways:

  • Mortgage Paydown: Each mortgage payment reduces your loan balance, automatically increasing your ownership stake in the property.
  • Appreciation: As your property’s value rises, so does your equity, even if your loan balance remains the same.

Why Equity Matters for Landlords

  • Wealth Building: Over time, growing equity increases your net worth and creates financial stability.
  • Leverage for Future Investments: You can tap into your equity through refinancing or a home equity loan to fund property improvements or purchase additional investments.
  • Increased Resale Profits: The more equity you have, the larger your potential profits when selling the property.

Maximizing Equity Growth

  • Make Extra Payments: Contributing extra toward your principal can accelerate equity growth.
  • Maintain the Property: Regular upkeep preserves the value of your home and protects your equity.
  • Invest in Appreciation: Focus on properties in desirable areas where values are likely to increase.

Building equity is a gradual process, but over time, it becomes a powerful tool for wealth creation, making renting out your home an even smarter financial move.

  1. Leverage

Leverage is the use of borrowed money (typically a mortgage) to purchase a property, allowing you to control a high-value asset with less cash upfront. It’s one of the most powerful tools in real estate investing, enabling landlords to maximize returns on investment while preserving their capital.

When you buy a property with a mortgage, you’re using the lender’s money to cover most of the purchase price. For example, with a 20% down payment on a $300,000 home, you control the full property while only investing $60,000 of your own money. As the property appreciates or generates rental income, your returns are calculated on the total property value—not just your down payment.

Benefits of Leverage

  • Higher ROI: Since your initial investment is smaller, the return on that investment can be significantly larger when property values increase.
  • Preserve Capital: Leverage allows you to invest in multiple properties or diversify your portfolio by requiring less cash upfront.
  • Inflation Hedge: As property values rise over time, the debt on the mortgage remains fixed, making leverage more advantageous in an inflationary market.

Risks of Leverage

  • While leverage amplifies gains, it can also magnify losses. If the property value drops or rental income doesn’t cover expenses, you’re still responsible for repaying the loan. High leverage can also lead to negative cash flow, especially with unexpected vacancies or repairs.

Tips for Using Leverage Wisely

  • Aim for Positive Cash Flow: Ensure your rental income covers the mortgage and other expenses.
  • Avoid Overleveraging: Keep a manageable loan-to-value (LTV) ratio to reduce risk.
  • Build Reserves: Have an emergency fund to cover payments during vacancies or slow market periods.

Leverage is a double-edged sword, offering the potential for substantial returns while requiring careful risk management. When used wisely, it can be a game-changer in building wealth through real estate.

Conclusion

Renting out your home can be a fantastic way to generate income, build equity, and take advantage of powerful financial tools like depreciation, appreciation, and leverage. For military families and government employees navigating frequent relocations, it offers an opportunity to turn a personal home into a long-term investment. However, renting successfully requires a clear plan, careful financial evaluation, and a willingness to tackle the responsibilities of property management.

Start by defining your goals, analyzing your numbers, and consulting professionals when needed. With the right approach, your home can become more than just a place to live—it can be a key part of your financial future. 

Ready to take the next step? Contact me on my website for a free real estate consultation to review your plan and explore how turning your home into a rental could support your financial goals and future.